In our webinar last night, someone brought up a common journal question: Which is better–writing by hand or using a keyboard?
Some people love the experience of the movement of arm and hand with pen or pencil moving across paper and the soothing sounds of the scratching against the page. Others like the feel of fingers tap dancing on the keyboard accompanied by the rhythmic click-clacking of keys. I think that journal writing should include a comfortable physical experience with both pleasant touch and auditory sensations.
I think those of us who were born prior to the 1970s may naturally feel more at home writing with a pen on paper. However, even those of us who didn’t grow up with computers during our teen or young adult years have learned to be comfortable with a keyboard.
Some of us note the division of our writing tools: keyboarding at work and handwriting for pleasure. Others feel that their handwriting is so slow and illegible that keyboarding has its advantages, regardless where you are.
Still others feel that the handwriting/keyboarding schism figures in to where their writing originates: handwriting is more connected to their hearts and keyboarding is more connected to their brains. (Often I’ve been able to reach a trancelike state where I can close my eyes and type on a keyboard with the comfort and ease of heartfelt writing that bypasses the brain. It’s almost impossible to close one’s eyes and handwrite legibly. So I think there are ways to bridge the heart/brain gap in keyboarding.)
I would think that those of us over 30 years old have some ambivalence—sometimes keyboarding works for journal writing, sometimes handwriting is preferable. So how to resolve this dilemma??
Like most decisions, deciding to journal on keyboard or paper is a question of trade-off and balance. A key question is whether the advantages of a computer journal (privacy, organization, inspiration, comprehensiveness, and search-ability) outweigh the benefits of the comfort of handwriting. And then—-I can always hope that there’s a way to have my cake and eat it too. I’m a fan of that option, whenever possible. So in LifeJournal I created the have-it-all option:
LifeJournal, journal software (www.lifejournal.com) has a feature that lets you index your writing. For those times that you feel like you just have to handwrite, do so. Later, you can include that entry into a LifeJournal entry. Open a LifeJournal entry and enter the date of your handwritten entry and give it a title. Then in the body of the LifeJournal entry, write a description of the journal (e.g. the green spiral notebook) with the page number where the handwritten entry can be found. You can assign topic(s) to this “placeholder” LifeJournal entry. And if you have passages in the handwritten entry that you really feel are important, type the portions of the entry, so that it is quickly accessible. Then, in the journal entry toolbar, there’s a button that toggles between “typed” and “handwritten.” By default the button is in the “typed” mode; click on it and it toggles to “handwritten.” When you perform a search (using the Advanced Search dialog), you can select/deselect “handwritten entries” in your search.
So, no need to make an either/or choice. You can integrate both your typed and handwritten entries with LifeJournal while you are eating your cake.